Almost Peaceful: My Journey of Healing from Binge EatingFriendship, Listening, and Empathy: A Prayer GuideDraw Near: A Lenten Devotional Two Hands: Grief and Gratitude in the Christian LifeSabbath Keeping: Finding Freedom in the Rhythms of Rest Fasting: Spiritual Freedom Beyond our AppetitesA Renewed SpiritualityNurturing Hope: Christian Pastoral Care in the Twenty-First CenturyThe Power of ListeningJoy Together: Spiritual Practices for Your CongregationPrayers of the New TestamentPrayers of the Old TestamentPersonality Type in CongregationsSabbathA Garden of Living Water: Stories of Self-Discovery and Spiritual GrowthDead Sea: A NovelDeadly Murmurs: A NovelDeath in Dunedin: A NovelBeating Burnout in CongregationsReaching Out in a Networked WorldEmbracing MidlifeFriendingAdvent Devotional

Communal discernment of the heart of the Gospel, parts 3 and 4

Lynne Baab • Thursday June 4 2026

Communal discernment of the heart of the Gospel, parts 3 and 4

Overall theme for January to July: God’s law is love

Lesson 9: Communal discernment of the heart of the Gospel, parts 3 and 4 (Acts 15:1-21)

Key verse: “God, who knows the human heart . . . has made no distinction between them and us.” Acts 15:8-9

Keeping God’s grace at the center

The discussion at the Jerusalem council is grounded in two events in the early years of the church. In his speech in Acts 15:7-11, Peter refers back to the dramatic series of events described in Acts 10, when God gives Peter a vision of all food being “clean,” a reference to Jewish dietary laws. Peter comes to understand the meaning of his vision when he receives a visit from Cornelius, a Gentile. Peter then preaches to a group of Gentiles, who receive the Holy Spirit. Peter responds in obedience to God’s guidance, and Peter also sees the work of the Holy Spirit in Gentile Christians. At the Jerusalem Council, Peter is able to draw on his conviction born from a dramatic vision and its results.

A second foundational event is described in Acts 13:1-3, when the Holy Spirit directs the Christians in Jerusalem to set apart Paul and Barnabas to preach the Gospel to the Gentiles. Paul and Barnabas, as they return to Jerusalem from their first missionary journey, are full of stories about the amazing work of the Holy Spirit among the Gentile believers. The Christians in Jerusalem, as they listen to the stories, remember that pivotal moment when the Holy Spirit called them to commission Paul and Barnabas for a new kind of ministry.

Like Peter, Paul, and the Christians in Jerusalem, our lives of faith are grounded in our past experiences with God. We look back and remember the ways God’s Spirit has been teaching and shaping us, and we base our decisions, both communal and individual, on what we know of God.   

In Galatians 2, Paul describes his conflict with Peter about instructing Gentile Christians to obey the Jewish law. The conflict in Galatia may have come before or after the council described in Acts 15. If Galatians came first, then Acts 15 gives us a glimpse of what Peter learned from Paul in the conflict in Galatia. If Acts 15 came first, then we see Peter reverting to previously held views when he visits Galatia, but we also see a man who allows Paul to help him change course. Either way, we encounter a man who is open to God’s Spirit working within him to learn God’s ways in new forms.

The topic of the controversy in Acts 15 remains significant today. Do our words and and interactions, as individuals and as faith communities, slip into any form of legalism that emphasizes measuring up to external standards rather than receiving mercy and love from the God who created and redeemed us? Do our church ministries, preaching, and teaching sufficiently emphasize God’s grace?

What events do you look back on that help you remember God’s grace poured into your heart by the Holy Spirit?

Stepping into the world

One challenge of Christian ministry is discerning the theological issues at stake in our decision making. For Paul and Peter at the Jerusalem council, the theological issue was clear. To require Gentile Christians to obey the Jewish law would negate the grace of God, shown in Jesus’s life, death, and resurrection. If God brings people to Christ without the aid of the law, we shouldn’t impose that law on them later.

In conflicts in our church committees and boards, we may wish for the clarity experienced by Peter in Acts 10 and the early church in Acts 15. Discernment today often feels challenging. God’s voice feels muddled in the midst of so many competing voices. The various strategies advocated for communal Christian decision making — such as prayer, careful listening, and willingness to take enough time to hear the guidance of the Holy Spirit — are grounded in patterns of discernment modeled in Acts, as well as values found throughout the Bible. The council in Jerusalem also shows the significance of the role of the Holy Spirit.

Paul recounts stories of the Holy Spirit’s surprising work among the Gentile Christians. Peter remembers seeing the Holy Spirit fall on Gentiles. These stories show the importance of looking for God’s Spirit at work and being willing to talk with our brothers and sisters about what we see. We are sometimes reluctant to talk about the Holy Spirit, in part because of discomfort with this enigmatic person of the Trinity and also because of the great challenge of discerning precisely when and where the Spirit is moving. How can we be sure that something we see is actually the result of the Holy Spirit’s action?

Peter asks why the Jewish Christians are “placing on the neck of the disciples a yoke that neither our ancestors nor we have been able to bear” (Acts 15:10). God accepts us because of Jesus, not because of anything we do, including obedience to rules or laws. God’s grace is our foundational principle, the guiding star of everything we do. God’s grace will play a central role whenever the Holy Spirit is at work, and Jesus will be honored. Discerning where exactly the Holy Spirit is leading requires a great deal of time for reflection, discussion, attentive listening, and especially prayer. It is no accident that when the disciples in Jerusalem hear the Holy Spirit guiding them to commission Paul and Barnabas for ministry to the Gentiles, these Christians are already worshipping, fasting, and praying (Acts 13:1-3). Prayer is essential for discernment and guidance from God. 

How does prayer help you, and your community of faith, keep God’s grace at the center and recognize the action of the Holy Spirit?

֍ ֍ ֍

Two ways to subscribe.

If you’d like to receive an email when I post on this blog, sign up below under “subscribe.” That email and the posts on this blog are free and accessible for all.

If you’d like to help me cover the expenses for this blog and website, plus get a bonus post every month, you can subscribe on Patreon for $3 or $6 per month. My bonus posts focus on one or more of the hundreds of vivid quotations I’ve collected over five decades.

֍ ֍ ֍

Next week: Love fulfills the law. Illustration by Dave Baab (a wonderful tribute to Dave and his art is here).

Previous posts about grace:

This lesson appeared in the Fall 2023 edition of The Present Word adult Bible study curriculum published by the Presbyterian Publishing Corporation. Used with permission.



Next post »« Previous post